Showing posts with label asthma history. Show all posts
Showing posts with label asthma history. Show all posts

Thursday, November 12, 2015

400 B.C.: Did Hippocrates recognize allergies?

While hay fever was not mentioned until the 19th century, and allergies not defined until the 20th century, the signs and symptoms of allergies were well known to physicians of the ancient world.  Perhaps the first allusion to this was by Hippocrates during the 5th century.

Claude Lenfantt, in his introduction to the book "The Immunological Basis of Asthma, quotes Hippocrates as saying: 
Cheese does not harm all men alike, some can eat their fill of it without the slightest hurt, nay, those it agrees with are wonderfully strengthened thereby.  Others come off badly.  So the constitution of these men differ, and the difference lies in the constituent of the body which is hostile to cheese, and is roused and stirred to action under its influence. (1, page introduction)
Since Hippocrates probably obtained his medical wisdom from his ancestors, who were probably teachers at the Asclepion at Cos, we can probably surmise that physicians going back to the early ancient world observed the symptoms of allergies.

Surely allergies caused grief and suffering for those afflicted with it, this would have been minor compared to all the diseases that plagued the ancient world.  So allergies, even more so than asthma, was essentially ignored by the medical community.  The symptoms were probably recognized and brushed aside as catarrh, or the common cold.

References:

  1. Lenfant, Claude, author of introduction, Bart Lambrecht, Henk Hoogsteden, Zuzana Diamant, editors, "The Immunological Basis of Asthma," Lung Biology of Health and Disease, Volume 174, Claude Lenfant, executive editor, 2003, New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc. 

Tuesday, September 15, 2015

1940: Asthma death rate begins a gradual rise

The 1940s was a significant century in the history of medicine, as advances in medicine resulted in declines of morbidity and mortality from some of histories deadliest diseases, such as consumption and influenza.  Our asthma history saw an opposite trend.  While asthma morbidity and mortality were negligible through the 1930, they started to gradually climb during the fourth decade of the 20th century.

Considering these other diseases were in the forefront of the general public, the spike in asthma deaths nearly went unnoticed. Some experts may have seen what was going on, although they had no way of even guessing at the cause.  The reason was because most of the public's attention remained on other diseases, with all public funds, therefore, not going for asthma research.  For this reason there was very limited data regarding asthma available to review.

That left researchers to reviewing death certificates.  However, many experts wondered if methods of certifying death certificates were even accurate.  There were probably times when asthma was misdiagnosed and under diagnosed.  A middle aged man with bronchitis may have been misdiagnosed with asthma.  A child with asthma may have been misdiagnosed with asthma. Likewise, a child with asthma may have gone unrecognized, and therefore undiagnosed.

It actually wasn't until the 1960s when all eyes were opened to the rising death rates that death certificates were reviewed.  The experts decided to limit their research to asthmatics between the ages of 5 and 35.  The reason was that the likelihood of having pure asthma was greatest among this age group.  Those under five were hard to diagnose, and those over 35 had a a greater likelihood of having some other disease combined with asthma.  Figuring out which one resulted in death could sometimes be difficult to determine.

Data was collected from as far as 1900 for this age group.  According to Beasley, Pearce and Crane in 1968, here is what was learned:
Those Western countries in which relevant data have been published indicate that asthma mortality was uniformly low and relatively stable between 1900 and 1940.  The death rate began to increase gradually in the 1940s in a number of countries including New Zealand and Australia, in which a threefold increase over a 15-year period was observed.  Mortality declined again in the late 1950s in New Zealand, England, and Wales, but not Australia.  In contrast, little change in asthma mortality rates was observed in the United States during this period.  Although the interpretation of death rates over such an extended period is difficult, the historical data are likely to be acceptable accuracy in this age group." (1, page 14)
They also made one other observation:
It is interesting to note that isoprenaline was introduced in a nebulizer formulation during the 1940s when mortality began to increase, but whether this had a role in the increase in mortality was not examined in detail at the time. (1, page 14)
Trends in asthma related deaths were not significantly studied until the 1960s.  When this was done, one of the theories that arose for the rise of asthma deaths in the 1940s was the availability of nebulized isoprenaline at home.  Theorists sense this may have created a false sense of security among asthmatics, particularly children.  Where they once would have sought help, they now simply resorted to their rescue medicine.

Isoprenaline was a new line of sympaththeomimetic medicines, also known as beta adrenergic medicine, more recently as asthma rescue medicine.  Regardless of what it is called, it has the tendency to provide immediate relief from an asthma attack.  Having access to such medicine was a godsend for asthmatics, because it meant that they could get immediate relief in the convenience of their own homes.

While physicians were happy to provide such an opportunity to asthmatics, they were not ready for the potential consequences.  Allowing asthmatics to have quick access to such rescue medicine resulted in two things.
  1. Overuse of isoprenaline may have resulted in cardiac arrest. This would have resulted in suden death from isoprenaline overdose secondary to asthma. 
  2. Overuse of isoprenaline may have resulted in tolerence to the medicine. This would have made the asthma refractory to the isoprenaline, resulting in increased dosing. By the time the asthmatic gave up on the isoprenaline, it was too late. 
These were simply theories that were never proven.  It as impossible for researchers to question these asthmatics after they died, and therefore it was impossible to know how much isoprenaline they used, if any.  
However, in many instances, there were reports from family members and friends of these asthmatics using their rescue medicine prior to death.  

For these asthmatics, however, such theories were trivial and too late. Although data obtained from studying how they died may have resulted in safety precautions that saved the lives of many future asthmatics.  In this way, the experts made sure these asthmatics did not die in vane. 

Another good thing that came out of the rise in asthma deaths during the 1940s, and later in the 1960s, was better recognition of our disease by the medical community.  This ultimately resulted in better recognition by the public, and therefore better funding for future research.  

However, as morbidity and mortality from asthma still remained low in comparison to other diseases, the rise in public awareness continued to pale in comparison.  While it's sad to say, many asthmatics continued to suffer from their disease because the general public simply was not paying attention.     

References:
  1. Beasley, Charles Richard William Beasley, Neil Edward Pearce, Julian Crane, authors of chapter two in the book "Fatal Asthma" edited by Albert L. Sheffer, 1998, New York, Hong Kong, Marcel Dekker, Inc. Chapter two is titled "Worldwide trends in asthma mortality during the twentieth century."
  2. Woolcock, Ann Janet, author of chapter 14 of the book, "Fatal Asthma," edited by Albert L. Sheffer, 1998, New York and Hong Kong, Marcel Dekker, Inc. Chapter 14 is titled "Natural Histor of Fatal Asthma."
  3. Sears, Malcolm R., "author of chapter 29 in the book "Fatal Asthma," edited by Albert L. Sheffer, 1998, New York and Hong Kong, Marcel Dekker, Inc.  Chapter 29 is titled "Role of B-Agonists in Asthma Fatalities."
  4. Jackson, Mark, "Asthma: The Biography," 2009, New York, Oxford University Press
  5. Bisgaard, Hans, Chris O'Callaghan, Gerald S. Smaldone, editors, "Drug Delivery to the Lung," 2001, New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc
  6. Mittman, Gregg, "Breathing Space," 
  7. Speizer, F.E., R. Doll, P. Heaf, "Observations on Recent Increase in Mortality from Asthma," British Medical Journal, February 10, 1968, 1, pages 335-339
  8. Altman, Lawrence K., "The Public Perception of Asthma," Chapter one of the book "Fatal Asthma," edited by Albert L. Sheffer, New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc, pages 3 and 11
  9. Speizer, F.E., R. Doll, P. Heaf, and B. Strang, "Investigation into use of drugs preceding death from asthma," British Medical Journal, 1968, 1, 339-343
  10. Sheffer, Albert L, "Partner Asthma Center's Grand Rounds," asthma.partners.org, http://www.asthma.partners.org/newfiles/ShefferFatalAsthma.html, accessed 10/5/13
  11. Bendy, Christine J., E.L-Fellah, R. Schneider, "Tolerance to sympathomimetic bronchodilators in guinea-pig isolated lungs following chronic administration in vivo," 1975, British Journal of Pharmacology, 55, pages 547-554
  12. Yarbrough, J.,  L.E. Lansfield, and S. Ting, "Metered dose inhaler induced bronchospasm in asthma patients," , Annals of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology," July, 1985, (55)1, pages 25-27
  13. Grant, Evalyn N., Kevin B. Weiss, "Socioeconomic risk factors for asthma mortality," chapter 17 of the book, Fatal Asthma," edited by Albert L. Sheffer, 1998, New York, Hong Kong, Marcel Dekker, Inc.

Tuesday, December 09, 2014

5000-50 B.C.: Hebrew health and healing

Each Hebrew village had a physician who specialized in medicine and a surgeon.  Some specialized in internal medicine, some external medicine, and others both.  (3, page 28-29) Permission to practice medicine had to be obtained by the magistrates where the physician wished to settle.  If you were sick (perhaps with asthma) you had the option of seeking out this physician to heal you.

This physician, however, also must obtain permission from the Beth-din, which was the council of the town.  Did the doctor have to pass a test? Was he interviewed? What questions were asked? Did he otherwise have to prove his competency? The answers to these questions remain a mystery, explains Robley Dunglison in his 1872 history of medicine. (4, page 31-32)

Jewish physicians were knowledgeable of the basics of anatomy, although their knowledge was quite primitive, as it was for most ancient societies.  They did not understand the concept of internal diseases, and the link between anatomy and disease.  However, as noted by Garrison, they did have a basic understanding of the most common diseases that left visible signs, such as leprosy, syphilis, phthisis, scabies, anthrax, epilepsy, and the various plagues (such as the plague of Ball Peor (numbers 25: 9) in which 24,000 perished. (7, page 59)

The best remedy was the one preached by Moses: good hygiene.  This included bathing, hand washing, sexual restraint, etc. Although, if someone did get sick, the remedies were simple.  For instance, the remedy for leprosy washing in the Jordan, or "dipping seven times in the Jordan. (2 Kings 5: 14)" (7, page 59-60)

These physicians were educated in "sanitary administration and jurisprudence," says Puschmann.  Along with good hygiene, they were also required to do other things to prevent disease, which included circumcision.  (3, page 28-29)  While modern experts think they have disproved this theory, ancient people believed uncircumcised penises were more likely to become infected.  This was how circumcision made its way into the Bible.

Physicians were also, as noted by Garrison, required to isolate people with infectious disease such as leprosy, syphilis, gonorrhea and leukorrhea, as noted in Leviticus 12-15. (7, page 60)  This was another significant measure of preventing healthy people from getting these diseases.  It must also have been observed that many diseases were spread through sexual contact, and so sexual abstinence prior to marriage was encouraged, and loyalty to one man or one woman was also encouraged.

Puschmann notes that when a person was sick he called upon his physician, who paid the sick a visit. Then the physician was paid by the sick or his family, and not by a collective tax. (3, page 28-29) Although, "Jewish medicine was almost exclusively a medicine of the state, not a private profession," writes Thomas Bradford in his 1898 book "Quiz questions on the history of medicine." (9, page 9)(5, page 31)

The neat thing about ancient people such as Egyptians, Greeks, Romans, and Hebrews, is you didn't have to be a physicians to be an expert in medicine, says Puschman. He explains this was because medicine was included in the list of knowledge  taught at schools.  It would be like going to college today for Journalism, and having to take classes in math, English and Business.  So many of the people mentioned in the Bible, particularly prophets such as Solomon, Elijah, Elisha and Ahijah, had medical wisdom, and this wisdom allowed them to "become famous for their successful cures."  (3, page 29)

Baas says King Solomon (who reigned 1020-980 B.C.) was a prophet who had the ability to cure, (2, page 32) and Bradford said of Solomon that "tradition attributes to him a medical work which taught how to cure diseases by natural means. Arabian authorities assert that he left a history of plants and animals, and a number of other works." (9, page 8)

There are various, and random, references to the healing powers of the prophets in the Bible.  Elisha, who lived in the 9th century B.C., healed the water that causes miscarriages:
Some men from Jericho went to Elisha and  said, "As you know, sir, this is a fine city, but the water is bad and causes miscarriages." Elisha said, "Put some salt in a bowl and bring it to me." They brought it to him, and he went to the spring, threw in the salt in the water, and said, "This is what the Lord says: 'I make this water pure, and it will not cause any more  deaths or miscarriages.'" And that water has been pure ever since, just as Elisha said it would be. (Kings 2: 19-22)
Elisha also resurrected a Shunammite's son:
When Elisha arrived, he went alone into the room and saw the boy lying dead on the bed.  He closed the door and prayed to the Lord.  Then he lay down on the boy, placing his mouth, eyes, and hands on the boy's mouth, eyes, and hands.  As he lay stretched out over the boy, the boy's body started to get warm.  Elisha got up, walked around the room, and then went back and again stretched himself over the boy.  the boy sneezed seven times and then opened his eyes.  Elisha calledGehazi and told him to call the boy's mother.  When she came in, he said to her, "Here's your son." She fell at Elisha's feet, with her face touching the ground; then she took her son and left." (Kings 4: 32-37) 
He also healed Naaman:
"Naaman was commander of the army of the king of Aram.  He was a great man in sight of his master and highly regarded.  because through him the Lord had given victory to Aram. He was a valiant soldier, but he had leprosy. Now bands of raiders from Aram had gone out and had taken captive a young girl from Israel, and she served Naaman’s wife.  She said to her mistress, 'If only my master would see the prophet who is in Samaria! He would cure him of his leprosy.'” (2Kings 5:1-2)
Naaman's master allowed him to see the king of Aram, who allowed Naaman to see the king of Israel for permission, although the king of Israel " tore his robes and said, “Am I God? Can I kill and bring back to life? Why does this fellow send someone to me to be cured of his leprosy? See how he is trying to pick a quarrel with me!”

The next passages says that: 

When Elisha the man of God heard that the king of Israel had torn his robes, he sent him this message: “Why have you torn your robes? Have the man come to me and he will know that there is a prophetSo Naaman went with his horses and chariots and stopped at the door of Elisha’s house.Elisha sent a messenger to say to him, “Go, washy ourself seven times in the Jordan, and your flesh will be restored and you will be cleansed.”   
But Naaman went away angry and said,
“I thought that he would surely come out to me and stand and call on the name of the Lord his God, wave his hand over the spot and cure me of my leprosy. Are not Abana and Pharpar, the rivers of Damascus, better than all the waters of Israel? Couldn’t I wash in them and be cleansed?” So he turned and went off in a rage. Naaman’s servants went to him and said, “My father, if the prophet had told you to do some great thing, would you not have done it? How much more, then, when he tells you, ‘Wash and be cleansed’!”So he went down and dipped himself in the Jordan seven times, as the man of God had told him, and his flesh was restored and became clean like that of a young boy. (2Kings 5:9-15)
To finish this neat story, Naaman offered payment, or at least to be a servant to the prophet, but Elisha would not take payment, saying, "go in peace."  Gehazi, the servant of Elisha, was upset that Elisha didn't take payment, and so he did so himself.  Elisha punished Gehazi:
But Elisha said to him, “Was not my spirit with you when the man got down from his chariot to meet you? Is this the timeto take money or to accept clothes—or olive groves and vineyards, or flocks and herds, or male and female slaves? Naaman’s leprosywill cling to you and to your descendants forever.” Then Gehazi went from Elisha’s presence and his skin was leprous—it had become as white as snow.(2Kings 5: 27-28)
In another Biblical story, King Asa (10th century B.C.) was king of Judah, and he was among the first kings to be faithful to the worship of God.  In fact, even his name, Asa, means physician.  He opposed idolatry and all immoral behavior.  Yet despite his faithfulness, when he was struck with disease at the end of his life, he consulted physicians instead of the Lord (2Chronicles 16: 12-14
"In the thirty-ninth year of his reign Asa was diseased in his feet, and his disease became severe; yet even in his disease he did not seek The Lord, but sought help from physicians. And Asa slept with his fathers, dying in the forty-first year of his reign. They buried him in the tomb which he had hewn out for himself in the city of David. They laid him on a bier which had been filled with various kinds of spices prepared by the perfumer's art; and they made a very great fire in his honor." (2Chronicles 16: 12-14
King Jeroboam, who died in 910 B.C., prayed to an old prophet for healing:
The prophet prayed to the Lord, and the king's arm was healed. (Kings I 13: 7) 
The prophet Elijah, who lived around 869-850 B.C., healed a widow's son:
"Give the boy to me," Elijah said.  He took the boy from her arms, carried him upstairs to the room where he was staying, and laid him on the bed.  Then he prayed aloud, "O Lord my god, why have you done such a terrible thing to this widow?  She has been kind enough to take care of me, and now you kill her son!" Then Elijah stretched himself out on the boy three times and prayed, "O Lord my god, restore this child's life!" The Lord answered Elijah's prayer; the child started breathing again and revived. (Kings I 17: 19-22)
Isaiah cured king Heekiah's illness:
Isaiah left the king, but before he had passed through the central courtyard of the palace the Lord told him to go back to Hezekiah, ruler of the Lord's people, and say to him, "I, the Lord, the god of your ancestor David, have heard your prayer and seen your tears.  I will heal you, and in three days you will go to the temple.  I will let you live fifteen years longer.  I will rescue you and this city Jerusalem from the emperor of Assyria.  I will defend this city, for the sake of my own honor and because of the promise I made to my servant David." (Kings II 20: 4-6)
There are many more references to health and healing in the Bible, from Adam all the way to Jesus.  Consider the following:Saying, “If you will diligently listen to the voice of the your God, and do that which is right in his eyes, and give ear to his commandments and keep all his statutes, I will put none of the diseases on you that I put on the Egyptians, for I am thehealer.” (Peter 2:24)
  • Is anyone among you sick? Let him call for the elders of the church, and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord. And the prayer of faith will save the one who is sick, and the Lord will raise him up. And if he has committed sins, he will be forgiven. Therefore, confess your sins to one another and pray for one another, that you may be healed. The prayer of a righteous person has great power as it is working. (James 5:14-16
  • And he called to him his twelve disciples and gave them authority over unclean spirits, to cast them out, and to heal every disease and every affliction. (Matthew 10:1)
  • And he went throughout all Galilee, teaching in their synagogues and proclaiming the gospel of the kingdom and healing every disease and every affliction among the people. (Matthew 4:23)
  • Another famous Biblical quote about healing is this, as quoted from Isaiah 53:5, and 1Peter 2:24: 
  • “But he was pierced for our transgressions, he was crushed for our iniquities; the punishment that brought us peace was upon him, and by his wounds we are healed."
The passage is not necessarily about medical healing, it's more spiritual healing.  Basically, by learning from the sins of others, we can be healed.  By not doing the evil things other people have done, the things that make you spiritually or physically sick, you will stay healthy, or be healed.

So the Bible, while not a medical texts, provides us with some vague information of medical wisdom from around 1500 to 1700 years before the birth of Christ. Most diseases at this time were best left to nature (4, page 30), as the remedies provided (bleeding, purging, emetics) often made the patient feel worse, and sometimes caused death.  The Bible offered a hope and a prayer, perhaps the best remedy of all.

Reference:  See "1700 B.C.: Hebrew Bible influences medicine"

Thursday, October 09, 2014

2000 B.C.: Assyrian physicians will treat your dyspnea

Of course there is no evidence of asthma in ancient Mesopotamia, although there is evidence the ancient Mesopotamian civilizations had knowledge of the lungs, and were aware that some symptoms,-- excessive sputum, cough, shortness of breath, etc., were caused by "poisons" inside the lungs. There is also evidence of remedies for the various lung ailments that were known, and even something that might be considered the first man made inhaler.  

Now, at what point the knowledge was obtained we can only speculate. Early on in human history asthma-like symptoms must have been observed, and over time someone must have speculated these symptoms were due to the lungs.  A basic anatomy of the lungs must have been known, because mankind had been cutting open animals for food since the beginning of time. And surely accidents occurred where a person was badly mangled, and his lungs were observed.  Surely this opened the door to pondering, and at some point the link was made between shortness of breath and the lungs. 

Somewhere in the course of time herbs were tossed into a fire and inhaled.  Now, when this happened for the first time your guess is as good as mine.  Since it was also known in ancient Egypt that inhaling herbal remedies was the best way to provide breathing relief, it's highly probable this knowledge was obtained at an early time, and then shared among the various tribes or families. However, the techniques used to inhale respiratory medicine in Mesopotamia were different than what was used in Egypt.  So this may be evidence the discoveries were isolated, although we may never know for sure. 

So let's say it's the year 2000 B.C., you live in ancient Assyria, and you are short of breath.  Your first thought may be: "What god is mad at me?" or "What did I do wrong?"  At first you just deal with it, because you don't want to be a burden, although as your shortness of breath continues, you finally decide to seek help.

A baru is sent to your home, and it is his job to diagnose you. He comes adorned with several necklaces made of precious stones, and they rattle as he dances around the fire.  He sings incantations while inspecting your body, makes occasional gestures, and then he closes his eyes and presses his hands together as if in prayer. He stands up and notifies your family that it is now time to interpret the omens.  Since you do not own much, you choose not to sacrifice one of your animals to allow the baru to inspect the liver.

When your brother fell sick years ago a baru visited him, and he wanted your parents to sacrifice one of your sheep.  However, your parents opted to go with the cheaper option, and the baru walked to a nearby pond and placed a few drops of oil on the water and watched how the oil reacted.  The oracle did not give a good sign for your brother, and he died a few days later. Once you saw a baru place a stick in the fire, and he determined by the way the flame continued in the gentle breeze your mother would live another year or so after injuries she obtained when she fell off a horse.

He also used this method to determine that there would be a drought, and the drought would last a long time.   Once there was no water nearby, so he placed the oil in to a cup.  While you were sitting with the baru later that night, you read what he wrote: (10, page 455)
If I drop oil on water, and the oil sinks and rises again.. it means bad luck for a sick man.
If a ring forms from the oil in eastern direction and remains thus it means: for a campaign that I shall undertake it and shall make plenty of booty; for a sick it means that he will recover.
If two rings develop from teh oil, one large, teh other small, the wife of the man will give birth to a boy; for a sick it means that he will recover
If the oil disperses and covers the cup, the sick will die; the army will be destroyed.
If the oil bubble moves in Eastern direction, the sick will die.  (10, page 463)
This time, however, the baru finds a sign from the gods right away.  While inspecting your home for signs of the wishes and voices of the gods, he observed birds flying over the right side of the home, and he determined that this is a good omen, one that means the gods wish you well and will allow you to live.  This is a sign that it is okay to treat you. (10, pages 453-454, 484)

Henry E. Sigerist, in his 1951 history of medicine, explains that descriptions of lung disorders are common in Mesopotamia.  He wrote:
'A man is affected in his lung passage' or 'suffers from teh "pipe of the lungs,"' means that the patient has a disease of the bronchi or upper respirtory organs.  An Assyrian tablet published by Labat and Tournay gives a good description of bronchitis: If the patient suffers from hissing cough, if his windpipe is full of murmurs, if he coughs, if he has coughing fits, if he has phlegm: bray together roses and mustard, in purified oil drop it on his tongue, fill, moreover, a tube with it and blow it into his nostrils.  thereafter he shall drink several times beer of the first quality; thus he will recover. (Sigerist, page 480-481)
Sigerist continues:
In the tables dealing with diseases of the chest, we have a number of diagnoses although they don not go beyond naming the organ affected. 'If a man's breast hurts him, his epigastrum burns him, his stomach (is inflamed (swolen)... that man has lung trouble.' (10, page 481)
If it is determined that the ailment plaguing you is pneumonia, "the treatment recommended in this case was very sensible. The chest was formented with water in which fennel had been boiled, after which balsamic poultices were applied.  this remained the treatment of pleurisy and pneumonia for several thousand years," writes Sigerist. (10, page 480)

He describes other symptoms of lung diseases, such as: (10, page 480)
  • A man "coughs dry, ejecting no saliva"
  • The "lungs cough up pus and the inward parts"
  • "A man is affected in his lungs and they vomit exceedingly"
  • '"f a man's lungs pant with his work"
  • "When the breath of a man's mouth is difficult"
  • "A man is affected in his lung passage"
  • "Suffers from the 'pipe of the lungs"
Sigerest says we can interpret these however  we like.  The use of "panting" and "difficult" may refer to shortness of breath, or dyspnea.  "Pus" and "inward parts" may be excessive sputum, or perhaps it means bleeding, hemorrhage. Although most of these passages must refer to "diseases of the bronchi or upper respiratory organs." (10, page 480)

So now an asu comes to your home carrying with him pottery jars.  He says, "The hands of a ghost are upon you." He chants an incantation, and says, "Your breathing is ailing because of 'restriction of breath.'  We will work with you to remove the ghost the baru says is possible to extricate.  I cannot promise you anything, yet what I offer is the best option for you." (10, page 420)

Sigerist also provides a description of a Mesopotamian remedy for lung disorders, and this may be ideal for your respiratory distress, and it may be that this is what the asu was thinking, and why he brought the two jars :
...If a man is affected in the lungs, thou shalt spread powder of tar over a thornfiore, let the smoke enter his anus... his mouth and nostrils, it shall make him cough (?): thou shalt bathe him with water of vitex: thou shalt anoint the whole of his body with curd: thou shalt bray linseed either in milk (?)..., bind on him for three days, and let his tongue hold honey and refined oil... (11)
Sigerist also writes about an ancient Mesopotamian inhaler:
Like their egyptian colleagues, the Assyrian doctors possessed an apparatus for inhalations.  A decoction of various drugs was placed into a pot, which was sealed with wheaten dough after a reed-tube had been inserted into it.  the pot was placed on fire and then: 'thou shalt put it (the tube) into his mouth, let him draw the steam up by the reed-tube into his mouth... it shall strike his lungs: for nine days thou shalt do this.' 
The baru had many other natural remedies he could prescribe, including a variety of fruits and vegetables, resins, gums, trees, shrubs, and minerals.  Like the ancient Egyptians, they also used a variety of stuff taken from animals, such as fat, blood and liver. Just about any animal's parts could be found useful, including cattle, sheep, goat, pig, donkey, dog, lion, wolf, fox, gazelle, mouse, frog, chicken, pigeon, raven, stork, swan, owl, falcon, and even vulture, according to Sigerist.  Vehicles used were "wines, beers, fats, oils, honey, wax and milk."(10, page 485-6)

Some drugs that they had access to that would some day benefit an asthmatic -- if it didn't happen already -- were hemp and opium.  (10, page 485)

During the course of the next few days you get better, and now your sister is sick.  The baru has a different diagnosis for her, and the asu a different treatment.  She is not prescribed a herbal remedy, only an incantation to site: (10, 464-465)
O! Ninlil, lady of teh gods, I have turned unto thee
To spare and to show favour thou knowest. thy mantle I have taken hold of
A heavy sin (?) I carry, I knkow not to bear it
Because of (my) transgression knkown and unknown I have become weak.
Because of the evil I have done and have not done I perish, O! lady,
(because) of the sin which since the time of my youth I have carried
And which the apostle of god has known or not known I suffer greatly
daily (?), O! my lady, may my evil be expelled.
May thy good breath blow and the darkness be brightened.
 From trouble and calamity that distress take thou my hand,
May not my offender prosper who exults over me
May I live, may I prosper and the greatness of thy great divinity ever shall I cherish
Later on you witnessed a 'a man sick with cough," and in this case the asu recommended the following:
Ground lolium, pounded roses, as mixture thou shalt mix, let him eat it in oil and honey; let him drink soup of pig's meat; when he goes to stool thou shalt light a fire before him, he shall direct it to his anus, and shall recover.
Sometimes people recovered after seen by the baru and asu, and sometimes not.  When they do it's due to the magic of the baru and the asu. When they don't it's because of the will of the gods.

Plus as in modern times, "drugs must have been prescribed occasionally merely because the patient expected something to be done," explains Sigerist.  So perhaps that inhaler the bure prescribed for you merely made you feel better by providing you with hope.

References here are for this post and all posts regarding ancient Mesopotamian medicine:  
  1. Wilder, Alexander, "History of Medicine: a brief outline of medical history and sects of physicians, from the earliest historic period; with an extended account of the new schools of the healing art in the nineteenth century, and especially a history of the american Eclectic practice of medicine, never before published," 1901, Maine, New England Eclectic Publishing Co.
  2. Baas, Joh Herman, "Outlines in the history of medicine and the medical profession," translated by H.F. Handerson, 1889, New York, J.H. Vail and Co. 
  3. Garrison, Fielding Hudson, "An introduction to the history of medicine, with medical chronology, suggestions for study, and bibliographic data," 3rd edition, 1922, Philadelphia and London, W.B. Saunders Company
  4. Roberts, J.M., "The illustrated history of the world: Volume 1: Prehistory and the first civilizations," 1998, New York, Oxford University Press
  5. "The Assiatic Journal, for British adn foreign India, China and Australia," volume VIII, New Series, May-August, 1832, London, Parbury, Allen and Co.
  6. Bradford, Thomas Lindsey, "Quiz questions on the history of medicine from the lectures of Thomas Lindsey Bradford," edited by Ray Roth, 1898, Philadelphia, John Joseph McVey
  7. Osler, William, "The evolution of the history of medicine: a series of lectures delivered at Yale University on the Silliman Foundation in April, 1913," 1922, New Haven, Yale University Press
  8. Gill, N.S., "Babylonian gods and goddesses," About.com, http://ancienthistory.about.com/cs/egypt/a/babygodsindex.htm, accessed 4/11/13
  9. Biggs, Robert G., "Medicine, surgery, and public health in ancient Mesopotamia," Civilization of the ancient Near East, edited by Jack M. Sasson, 1995, New York, Charles Scribner's Sons
  10. Sigerist, E. Henry, "A History of Medicine: Primitive and Archaic Medicine," volume 1, New York, Oxford University Press
  11. Sigerist, E. Henry, ibid, page 488, reference used by Sigerist: Thompson, Rev. Assyr.,1934, 31:18
  12. Martell, Hazel Mary, "Kingfisher Book of The Ancient World: from the ice age to the fall of Rome," 1995, New York, Larousse Kingfisher Chambers Inc. 
  13. Hopper, Anthony, "Five Important Phoenician Contributions to Western Medicine," Yahoo.com, http://voices.yahoo.com/five-important-phoenician-contributions-western-11972417.html, accessed 4/13/2013
  14. Foster, Leila Merrell, "The Sumerians," 1990, New York, London, Toronto, Sydney, 
  15. Morris, Jastrow, "The Civilization of Babylonia and Assyria," 1915, Philadelphia and London, J.B. Lippincott Company 

Tuesday, October 07, 2014

1840-1903: Open air treatment for consumption x

Figure 1 -1899, National Jewish Hospital, TB patients treated with sunlight (4)
Around the turn of the 20th century tuberculosis was a common ailment, and a leading cause of death.  Yet it also lead to a general feeling of gloom among the populace, especially considering little was known about it and there was no cure.  Yet if you had it there was hope, thanks to places like sanatoriums and hospitals like National Jewish Hospital for Consumptives in Denver Colorado.  

In the 1840s Hermann Brehmer (1826-1889) was diagnosed with the condition and he told his doctor he might benefit from the open air of the Himalayas.  He also decided there might be benefits from isolating tuberculosis patients from the rest of the community, so he created hydrotherapy institution in Gorbesdorf, which is a village in Silesia, Germany. 

Bre
At first he had trouble convincing the medical community he was on the right track, but ultimately he became so successful that various sanatoriums opened in mountainous areas all over Europe and the United States.  One famous one in the United States was built in Denver, Colorado in 1899 by the Jewish Community. 

Many of the Jewish Community who were struck with tuberculosis were flocking to the Denver area because of it's fresh, dry, mountainous air.  Yet many of these victims were without enough money to be able to afford food or housing.

This was brought to the attention of Frances Wishbart Jacobs who worked hard to raise money to build shelter for these destitute victims of consumption.  She was able to find support from members of the Jewish Community and then to generate enough money to build an institution.  (1)

National Jewish Hospital 1892
In 1892 Jacobs died, and a year later the building was finished.  Yet the country was also mired in a recessions that year prompted by the silver crisis, and this resulted in a lack of funds to open the facility.  The building laid empty until Rabbi William S. Friedman took up a project to complete and open the institution.  (2)

The doors to the National Jewish Hospital for Consumptives opened in 1899 with the motto: "None may enter who can pay -- none can pay who enter." (1)  While it was originally built by the Jewish Community, anyone was allowed to enter who needed help.  (2)

One of the original therapies for tuberculosis patients in Denver was to receive heliotherapy, which was sunlight therapy (See figure 1).  It was believed that sunlight would help them "combat the disease."  (3)  This type of therapy, along with open air therapy altogether, was supported by Thomas Beddoes (1803-49), who performed many tests on respiratory patients, and Herrmann Brehmer (1826-89), who, as noted, opened the first sanitorium.  (3, page 37)

Figure 4 -- Open air therapy for TB patient at his home (3, page 38)
Studies were also done that showed TB patients recover faster in the winter than summer months.  In fact, "Dr. Otto Walther says he not infrequently had an inch of snow on his blankets.  At some localities tents are the only shelter, but whether the patients are housed in cottages or in tents, the free access of air must be absolute and uninterrupted. Drafts are not feared. At night the windows, which should constitute at least one side of the room or ward, are kept open; in some places the sashes are removed altogether; the sides of the tents are rolled up, except in the severest storms. In very cold weather the head and hands may be protected with woolen cap and gloves, and at all times the patients are well provided with blankets. In summer the beds or reclining chairs are moved into the open or into covered porches during the day; for the winter most places are provided with glass porches or sun parlors; where the patients spend their days in bed or reclining in steamer chair." (3, page 38)

(5, page 44)
The benefits of open air therapy as reported were: (3, page 39)
  • Reduction of the fever
  • Improvement of the appetite,
  • Induction of sleep
As noted, "Cough and night-sweats disappear in a short time, and, as a logical consequence, the medicinal treatment is reduced to a minimum. Antipyretic drugs are never used and expectorants are rarely required. Suralimentation (the belief that consumption could be cured by forcing them to eat) is practised in many places, especially in the German resorts, where it is pushed to an almost incredible degree; even bed patients with considerable pyrexia are placed on a full diet of meat and vegetables. Trudeau and Flick * content themselves with giving their patients three full meals a day, allowing them to drink milk between meals if they have a desire for it; when, however, there is anorexia, the patient is given raw eggs beaten up with milk every two or three hours." (3, page 39)

While open air treatment was utilized "judiciously" and based on "individual cases," the therapy could also be recommended for home use as well. (See figure 4) Patients may also benefit from treatment in tents, walks or rides in the open air.  (3, page 39)

Another type of therapy was pulmonary gymnastics, or exercise.  While this was debated as an effective therapy, it was often recommended at the various sanatoriums.

In 1895 a German by the name of Wilhelm Konrad von Roentgen discovered the x-ray that allowed doctors to see the disease in its early as well as it's late stages.  This marked the first time that the disease could be diagnosed in its early stages instead of having to wait to see the late signs.  It also allowed doctors to see the tubercles in those who had survived the disease.  It showed both active and inactive tuberculosis.

References:
  1. Gurock, Jeffrey S., ed., "American Jewish History," 1998, New York, vol. 3, part 3, pages 1095-6
  2. "The History of National Jewish," NationalJewish.org, http://www.nationaljewish.org/about/whynjh/history/
  3. Tissier, Pneumotherapy
  4. Photo compliments of National Jewish Health, Facebook, http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10151140094301092&set=a.140185801091.110191.41885201091&type=1&theater, accessed on 10/20/12
  5. Picture from the Journal of the Outdoor Life," National Tuberculosis Association, Volume XI, January, 1914, 10 cents an issue or $1.00 a year

Thursday, September 25, 2014

1600-1700: Some abhorent remedies for asthma

So you have asthma in 1618, and you approach your physician about your problem. You sit in a wooden chair opposite his voluminous desk, leaning on his desk to expand your chest, your chest heaving with each slow breath.

As you're explaining your dilemma, in a huffy fashion, he opens a book on his desk.  You observe the title: "Materia Medica."  You wait as he sifts through the pages, and says, "hmmmmm.  Let's see here."  His finger traces what he's reading.  He leans back in his chair.  

He says, "Now, according to this "Materia Medica" we have a few options here.  Do you have anyone who can hunt for you."

You say, "Well, I'd love to hunt for myself, yet the consequences of doing it put me here."  

"I see." He leans back in his chair, puckers his lips as if in deep thought.

"So what do I need to do?" You ask.

"Well, it says here," he picks up the book, turns it so you can see the page, and he points to the heading "Asthma."  You read the section he's pointing to:
  • Worms
  • Lozenges of dried vipers
  • Foxes Lungs
You say, "Well, I think I can find someone to get me a fox, but I'm not sure about the viper.  I think getting one of those would be next to impossible." You look into the doctor's eyes.  "Don't tell me a viper bite will cure me, doctor."

Your comment induces a laugh from the doctor, and you join in briefly.  The laughter induces a cough, and you produce a large amount of sputum.  The doctor reaches into his desk and offers you a handkerchief.
-----------

For kicks and grins, here are some of the other remedies in 17th century pharmacopaeas:
  • Powder's of precious stones
  • Moss from the skull of the victum of violent death
  • Human urine
  • Blood
  • Fat
  • Bile
  • Horns
  • Crab's claws
  • Crab's eyes
  • Bones
  • Bone marrow
  • Sexual organs
  • Eggs
  • Excreta of animals of all sorts
  • Spider-webs
  • Fur
  • Feathers
  • Hair
  • Scorpions
No wonder physicians struggled to gain respect.  To their credit, though these remedies offered hope to patients, and there were also many other remedies that had an actual benefit to the patient.  Considering the medical ignorance of the time, physicians who offered such remedies must have felt good about their efforts to help a sick person.

Such remedies were slowly phased out of the pharmacopoeia, mainly due to the works of men like William Heberden (1710-1801) who championed to put "diseases upon a scientific basis," and "who did a most important service to therapeutics by dispelling current superstitions and banishing them forever from the pharmacopoeia" in his 1745 book "Essays on Mithridatium Theriaca."*  (1, page 370)

Obviously most of these abhorrent remedies were slowly phased out of the pharmacopoeia, particularly as better remedies were introduced.  For example, stramonium was introduced to the London Pharmacopoeia in 1721 by Sir Hans Sloane.  A few decades later, the authors of the 5th London Pharmacopeia of 1746 condemned the old practice of astrology and folk medicine, dropping the following remedies: (1, page 408)
  • Human fat
  • Spider Webs
  • Moss from human skulls
  • Unicorn's horn
  • Virgin's milk
  • Bones from stag's heart (1, page 408)
Can you guess what was in your asthma medicine?

*Mithridatium = remedy that cures everything, particularly poisons; theriaca = a compound of 64 drugs believed to be a cure for all poisons)

References:  
  1. Garrison, Fielding Hudson, "An introduction to the history of medicine," 1922, Philadelphia, W.B. Saunders Company, page 291

Thursday, September 18, 2014

950 B.C.: Solomon will heal your asthma

He was the son of David, the slayer of Goliath, and he reigned as King of Israel from 970-931 B.C. He is considered one of 48 Biblical prophets, and that means that he had healing powers. As an educated man, he most surely would have received knowledge of health and healing.  What this healing powers entailed no one knows..  

It is known that this man of great wisdom had healing powers, at least according to the Bible.  One example can be found in Acts of the apostles 5: 12-16:
And by the hands of the apostles were many signs and wonders wrought among the people; (and they were all with one accord in Solomon's porch.  and the rest durst no man join himself to them: but the people magnified them. And believers were the more added to the Lord, multitudes both of men and women.) Insomuch that they brought forth the sick into the streets, and laid them on beds and couches, that at the least the shadow of Peter passing by might overshadow some of them.  There cam also a multitude out of the cities round about unto Jerusalem, bringing sick folks, and them which were vexed with unclean spirits: and they were healed every one.
Perhaps among them were folks with asthma, or allergies, or bronchitis, or heart failure, or kidney failure or some other respiratory disorder. Perhaps it was a person who was near death, dyspeic due to failure of the various organs of the body.  All of these would have been healed through the healing powers of the prophet and King Solomon

Thursday, September 11, 2014

Asthma History: Introduction

According to my mother I was diagnosed with asthma at the age of two, which would be in the year 1972.  Considering she said I was sniffling, sneezing and wheezing even before that, chances are I developed asthma and allergies close to my birth on January 4, 1970.  Despite the claims of my doctors, I never outgrew my asthma.

When I was about ten-years-old, which would be in 1980, my asthma, already bad enough, took a turn for the worse.  While other kids were able to run around and have fun during recess, I was forced to sit on the bench.  While other kids were living normal lives, I was asking the Principal to call my mom because I couldn't breathe.

I remember my mother taking me to many unscheduled visits to Dr. Gunderson, and many more to the emergency room, and most of these for asthma.  Sometime in 1980 Dr. Gunderson introduced me to a small, pocket-sized device that gave me my breath back instantly.  It was an inhaler.  I quickly became great friends with this new object, taking it with me wherever I went.

One day as I was puffing on my inhaler I wondered what life would be like for asthmatics prior to modern medicine.  As I started to investigate this, I ended up on a journey that took me all the way back to the beginning of human existence 2.5 million years ago, and then all the way back to the current world.

I learned that for most of history (perhaps 99.9 percent of it) the asthmatic had to choice but to suffer through an attack.  Once I realized this I likewise realized how privileged I was to have been born in 1970, as compared with 1870 or, worse, 1870 B.C.

I also quickly learned that, as with the warpath of mankind, the path of disease can be traced back to the beginning of human existence.  In fact, disease may go back farther than war itself, as diseases exists regardless of the desires of mankind.  Although, as we learn from the Biblical Cain, fighting began early enough in a quest for selfish gain.

So while most histories follow the path of war, this history follows the path of health and healing, with an emphasis on asthma.  In order to organize this history I will use the following definitions:
  • Prehistory (prehistoric):  Time prior to the first written language, or recorded history, which is generally considered to be around 2700 B.C. 
  • Ancient:  Time after written language, or time with recorded history.  This period lasted from around 2700 B.C. until the fall of Rome in 476 A.D. 
  • Time:  After the birth of Christ people developed a need to keep track of time, and so the birth of Jesus was chosen as the date to begin time.  The date of his birth was estimated and this was chosen as 1 A.D. When a child is born we usually refer to the first year as zero.  With time the first 100 years is considered the first century, and therefore the years 100-199 were referred to as the 2nd century.  It's for this reason why the years 1900 to 1999 were referred to as the 20th century.  This is just how it is.  
This system was created to help people study history and keep track of dates and time.  Whether accurate or not, this is how history is recorded.  I will use this system to categorize this history of asthma:
  • Beginning to 5000 B.C.: Prehistoric people (prehistory)
  • 5000-2700 B.C.: Ancient Societies (Before History and Time)
  • 2700 B.C.-1 A.D.: Ancient Societies (During History, Before Time)
  • 1 A.D.-276 A.D.:  Ancient Societies (Beginning of Time)
  • 276 -1600 A.D.: Middle Ages (The Dark Ages of Medicine)
  • 1600-1800:  Age of Reason (The Age of Enlightenment)
  • 1800-1900:  The Scientific Revolution (the Age of Progress)
  • 1900-2000: The Age of Results
  • 21st Century:  The presents
  • My asthma story
Each chapter in this history is one blog post, and each will focus on one thought.  In this way I am able to keep each chapter pithy and, therefore, easy to read.  While I have done some of my own research, I try to tell this history through the eyes of those who lived it, or those who spent hours studying it.  This will, I think, give you a more complete picture of the history of asthma.  

However, considering the vastness of our history, and the brief time each person lived among it, this history is but a small glimpse of the past.  Most of our history is told by the select few privileged to be able to read and write, so it is nearly impossible to impress upon what life was like among the common folk.

Still, there was just enough evidence to draw a picture of what life must have been like for those who suffered from asthma over the years.

So what was it like to live with asthma in fill in location and year?  To best answer this question, I make a gallant effort to describe the the various cultures.  This, I think, should should allow us to gain a more complete understanding what it would be like to be sick if you lived among them.  

However, I would like you to consider the following quote from historian Henry E. Sigerist:
"We have no evidence whatsoever of any paleolithic medicine." (1, page 107)
I say this because there will be times throughout this history when we must use our imaginations to gain an understanding of what it was like to live with asthma in fill in the year and place.

So what was life like for asthmatics 2.5 million years ago?  Let's go!

Reference:
  1. Sigerist, Henry E "History of Medicine," volume I: Primitive and Archaic Medicine, 1951, New York, Oxford University Press

Thursday, September 04, 2014

2.5 million years ago: The dawn of empathy

The first humans walked the earth as early as 45,000 years ago.  Chances are these early people suffered from diseases such as asthma, and so this is where our history must begin. These are the people who ate the apples from the tree of knowledge, and who learned to have empathy for their fellow beings.  They therefore learned to not only feed and nurture themselves, but other people and animals as well.

Now we don't know if asthma existed back then, but let's assume it did.  Better yet, I'm certain asthma-like symptoms were probably felt by people when they were sick with infections, or perhaps as their heart and kidneys failed.  So let's assume a person 45,000 years ago was short of breath and gasping for air.  Observing his misery, another person would come to his aid, offering any help he could.

Now let us take this a step further.  While a human is a human is a human, there were human-like people who roamed the earth long before us.  Whether or not we evolved from them is up to you to decide, but there is a ton of evidence that they existed.  There is evidence they were able to adjust to various situations, and to make their own tools.  There is also evidence that as their brains grew, they developed the ability to ponder about the world around them, and to, well, love and have empathy.

Scientists have placed the first humanoids (something that resembles a human) as first appearing on earth as early as 7 million years ago, with the first human-like humanoids walking the earth 2-3 million years ago. The first human-like humanoids were called Home or Homo Habilis, meaning "handy or skillful," writes Patricia Netzley in her 1998 book "The Stone Age."   These humanoids were the first to adapt to their surroundings by inventing and using stone tools.  These tools were used for "scraping or sawing wood... cutting meat... cutting grass stems or reeds," writes Netzley. (1, page 9, 12)

They were the first to joint together at a "home base," where they shared food.  Food sharing, it must be understood, is among the first signs of empathy for people other than yourself.  It must have been a major challenge to not eat the food you hunted for yourself, and carry it to the base camp for someone else to eat.  Helping others by feeding them must have been the earliest form of healthcare or medicine. (1, page 41)

About 1.8 million years ago was a more human-like humanoid called home erectus, which means "upright man."  He walked the earth until about 300,000 years ago.  This was the first humanoid to experience a population crisis, and this meant that there were too many people in a given area for the available food.  This provided an incentive for them to migrate to where food was available.  This meant they were forced to adapt; to discover new lands, to find new food sources, to invent new tools, and invent new methods of living.  All of this would have been necessary in order to adapt to their new surroundings. (1, page 43-47)

The changing climate also forced them to migrate to places where it was cold, and they therefore were the first to discover the importance of fire sometime around 400,000 years ago.  At first they took advantage of natural fires that occurred due to lightning or lava, although eventually they learned to control fire themselves, and ultimately make it by themselves. (2, page 27)

While sitting around the fire home erectus had time to experiment, and he learned that meat could be cooked, and that this made food more tender and easy to chew.  They also experimented by cooking various plants, and learned that plants that were stiff or horrible tasting made for good food when cooked.  (2, page 27)So with less need for strong facial muscles to chew raw meat, some speculate fire may have contributed to the thinning out of the face and jaw (those who believe in the theory of evolution believe this anyway).

The first home sapiens, or "wise humans," first started walking the earth around 500,000 years ago.  Among the most well known of the home sapiens were the Neanderthals (Neandertals) who lived in small groups of about 25, mainly in caves, although they did have the ability to make crude shelters of materials they gathered from the woods. They had mastered the use of fire, and perhaps it was because of the fire that encouraged small groups of men and women to band together as small families or tribes, replete with men, women and children who worked together for a common cause (or so we can speculate). (1, page 52-60)

People who mastered the skill necessary to make and control fire were among the most important members of the family or tribe.  The knowledge they obtained often meant the difference between keeping warm or freezing; life or death.  The fires allowed them time to socialize, and to fall in love with other members of the family or tribe.  This is evidenced by the fact they buried their dead in decorated grave sites, and provided the dead with gifts to take with them to the next world. (2, page 27)

Neanderthal men, and the women who were without child, searched for food during the day, and they brought this food back to he cave to share with the women, children, and the sick.  Yes, there is evidence Neanderthals took care of the sick.  (1, page 52-60)  One burial site was discovered of a man with no right arm, and there is evidence he managed with one arm for many years before he died, probably aided by his fellow men and women. (3, page 37)

Some speculate that the fact Neanderthals took care of the sick and performed burial rituals, and celebrated the life of the dead following these rituals, is evidence they had traditions.  The fact they had traditions is evidence, some suggest, that they had language.  This would have allowed one generation to communicate with the next, perhaps by easy to remember lyrics, or perhaps they just grunted (we just don't know). (1, page 61-63)

What we do know is Neanderthals thrived in Europe through hot and cold temperatures.  Their short, stocky frames required about twice as much food as we eat, and to do this they "lived around the edges of forests where they hunted large animals like red deer, horse and wild cattle. The forests gave them firewood, and materials to construct shelters and spears," according to bbc.co.uk science and nature. (3)

Then "About 45,000 years ago, the climate of Europe went through a burst of very sudden switches between warm and cold conditions that would have transformed the Neanderthals' environment. The forests on which they depended began to recede, giving way to open plains.  On these plains, Professor Shea believes, the Neanderthal thrusting spear and ambush strategy wouldn't have worked. So Neanderthals retreated with the forests, their population falling as their hunting grounds shrank," according to bbc.co.uk science and nature.  (3)

When humans migrated to Europe around 30,000 years ago, their "better brains and more sophisticated tools" were no match for the Neanderthals, who shortly thereafter became extinct. Human  tools and methods of adjusting made them better able to hunt amid and survive amid the the landscape created by mother nature.(3)

Now, where did these humans come from.  Those of us who are Christians believe they were placed on this earth by God.  Others believe they evolved from the Neanderthals or some other humanoid species.  Others believe in some combination of these two theories.  Believe it or not, there are many Christians who believe there is far too much evidence to prove evolution, and therefore believe there is room for both Christianity and evolution.  So, then, if this is the case, then God created the earth and the humanoids long before the Biblical date for the creation of time, which is pegged by some to be around 4004 B.C. (I will delve into this date more later).

I'll let you believe as you wish.  All we are concerned about here is what would asthma be like if we lived among these people?  We have no idea.  There is no written record, and there is no evidence of asthma left behind.  Asthma doesn't make its way to bones, which is mainly all we have left of these prehistoric people.  As a matter of fact, asthma leaves no visible scars, not even among the living. So what was it like to live with asthma 2.5 million years ago?  What was it like to live with asthma among the Neanderthals?  All we can do is speculate.

The truth is: we don't even know when asthma began to appear as a disease. What we can, I think, speculate accurately, is that people probably did get short of breath, or winded, since the beginning of time.  I can imagine that early humans had bodies that wore out early on in life.  Their kidneys started to shut down, and their hearts started to fail, and this would have caused you typical signs of respiratory distress; they would gasp for air, what the ancient Greeks would call asthma (more on the ancient Greeks later also).

It's also highly probable that many of the bacteria and viruses that plague humanity to this day irritated humanoids and early humans who walked the planet.  These germs entered the air passages, or were ingested by dirty hands, and made their way to places in the body they don't belong.  Prehistoric immune systems worked overtime to expectorate these germs, and this resulted in inflammation, including inflammation of the respiratory tract.  This would cause a runny and stuffy nose, itchy and watery eyes, scratchy throat, and even shortness of breath.

So in a world where humanoids and humans became increasingly empathetic toward their fellow men and women, in a world where they grew dependent on one another, in a world where they grew attached to one another, in a world where they fell in love with one another, they would most assuredly have felt sad when a parent, brother, sister, or friend, became ill in this way.  They would want to help out.  They would hunt and bring back food and water.  They would speculate as to the cause, and provide what they thought was the remedy.  Sometimes what they did would work, and the remedy would be remembered.  More often, however, the remedy would fail, and sadness would ensue.

So we can see here that as far back as 2.5 million years ago such people had the ability adapt to their surroundings, and they had the ability to make stone tools and use them to hunt and prepare food. Human-like people as early as the lower paleolithic (2.5 million to 126,000 years ago) had the ability to adapt to their surroundings, and to ponder about the world around them.

References:
  1. Netzley, Patricia D, "World History Series: The Stone Age," 1998, San Diego, CA, Lucent Books
  2. Roberts, J.M., "The illustrated History of the World: Prehistory and the first civilizations: volume I," 1999, New York, Oxford University Press
  3. "Neanderthal: Their bodies were well equopped to cope with the ice age, so why did the Neanderthals die out when it ended," bbc.co.uk, Science and Nature, http://www.bbc.co.uk/sn/tvradio/programmes/horizon/neanderthal_prog_summary.shtml, accessed 4/4/13
  4. Garrison, Fielding Hudson, "An Introduction to the history of medicine," 1922

Thursday, August 07, 2014

4004 B.C.: The beginning of Time?

At some point early on in human existence men and women grew curious about the their surroundings, and they began to ask questions.
In essence, as the Biblical allegory says, they ate from the tree of knowledge.

Thus, as noted by Alexander Wilder in his 1901 "History of Medicine:"
By such eating of the Tree of Knowledge, the eyes become open, and the man is as a god. He makes “the divinest conquest of the human intellect." (1, page 2)
When was this tree of knowledge planted, no one knows for sure.  According to the Bible God created Adam and Eve, and they lived in the Garden of Eden, and this was the beginning of time.  According to Patricia D. Netzley, in her 1998 book "The Stone Age," "some editions of the King James bible even offered the date of Creation: as 4004 B.C.  This date was developed by a religious scholar, an Irish archbishop named James Usher, who used time reference in the bible to construct a system of biblical chronology."  (5, page 18)

This actually makes sense, considering a written language was supposedly invented in Mesopotamia around 3200 B.C., and subsequently this language made its way to Egypt.  This means it was at about this time when all the information from the past was written down for the first time, information such as:

  • Myths
  • Legends
  • Religions
  • Laws
  • Recipes for foods
  • Recipes for remedies
Prior to this time this information was relayed by word of mouth, probably by words turned into lyrics and relayed by poems recited or songs sung around the fires late in the evening under the moonless sky, or somewhere on a cold and snowy evening in a cave around a warm fire.  Now that there was an ability to write, this information was recorded.  

Since there was no ability to write prior to about 3200 B.C., each generation had to start from scratch, and so it's probable the information relayed must have been kept very simple. The stories about the past were probably kept very simple, as can be noted by some of the early Biblical stories.  For example, the story of Adam and Eve is very short, probably because it was so long ago.  It only makes sense mankind wouldn't be able to remember stories from more than 800 years before their time, with the most distant passages in the Bible dating to about 4004 B.C. 

Interestingly enough, this date was believed to be accurate, and according to the people who wrote the Bible is was accurate given the limited knowledge of human history at that time.  When people found stone tools of primitive humans, they were classified as things like "petrified thunderbolts, fairy arrows, exhalations of the clouds," writes Netzley.  By the 1600s, however, "scholars suggested that these ancient items might somehow be related to human activity."  (2, page 17-18)

Historians have proven that the stories in he Old Testament really did happen, and provide us with an accurate depiction of human history.  However, there is evidence that human activity persisted long before he beginning of Biblical times.  There is also evidence of knowledge, diseases, remedies, and even doctors prior to 4004 B.C.

References:

  • Wilder, Alexander, "History of Medicine, a brief outline of medical history and sects of physicians, from the earliest historic period; with an extended account of the new schools of the healing art in the nineteenth century, adn especially a history of the American eclectic practice of medicine, never before published," 1901, Maine, New England Eclectic Publishing Co.
  • Netzley, Patricia D, "World History Series: The Stone Age," 1998, San Diego, CA, Lucent Books

Tuesday, August 05, 2014

2640 B.C.-1820 A.D.:First descriptions of hay fever

Like asthma, allergies were probably prevalent early in human history.  Yet the symptoms of a runny nose, sniffly, sneezes and wheezes, along with red and watery eyes, were probably confused with other maladies, such as asthma or influenza. So there were only random mentions of the malady before it was formally defined by the medical community in 1819.  

About 2,640 years before the birth of Christ, King Menses of Egypt was reported to have died after being stung by a wasp. As far as historians are aware, this is the first account of an allergic reaction.  So it's evident allergies go all the way back to the ancient world.   


Right around this time a Middle Eastern Physician named El-Razi observed redness and swelling of the nasal passages in some of his patients.  He described what we might consider allergic rhinitis or hay fever.  Yet those terms weren't used until the 19th and 20th centuries.

Arnoldo Cantani, in his book, "Pediatric Allergy, Asthma and Immunology," describes how Caesar Augustus suffered from asthma and seasonal rhinitis (allergies/ hay fever).  Caesar is also believed to have suffered from asthma. (1)

Roman Emperor Claudius (10-13 B.C to 54 A.D) is believed to have suffered from allergy symptoms, and his son Brittanicus (41?-55 A.D.) is believed to have suffered from an allergy to horses. Historical reports have it that when exposed to horses his eyes would swell up and he'd develop a rash.

Princes Nero and Brittanicus
Brittanicus was heir apparent to the throne.  Yet due to his allergies he was limited in what he could do.  And when his mother died, Claudius remarried to Agrippina the Younger.  She had a son named Nero, and Claudius adapted him.  Nero almost immediately won the favor of the public, and Nero ultimately eclipsed his younger brother and was named Emperor in 54 A.D.

Nero would ultimately become famous for throwing Christians to the Lions.  Yet within only a few months of his reign, he is believed to have poisoned his weaker, older brother Brittanicus to death.

Paul M. Ehrlich and Elizabeth Shimer Bowers, in their 2008 book "Living with Allergies," note that it was an Ancient Roman Physician who was the first to describe allergies.  The authors quote Lucretius, who lived from 99-55 B.C., as saying, "What is good for some may be fierce poisons for others." (2, page 4)

Physicians around  850 A.D. observed many of their patients developed sneezing, nasal stuffiness and runny noses when the roses were blooming.  Upon further examination they observed redness and swelling in the nasal passages that resulted in the runny nose, and they referred to this condition as rose fever.

The medical term catarrh was first used to describe the miserable condition that result in a runny nose around 1350 and 1400 A.D, according to dictionary.com.  The term catarrh comes from the Greek word katarrous which means "literally down-flowing."  So the term catarrh refers to the redness and swelling of the nasal passages that results in nasal drainage regardless of the cause.  It was a term commonly used by physicians through the 19th century.

King Richard III
Ehrlich and Bowers mention how legend has it that King Richard III (1452-1485) knew he had an allergy to strawberries and he used this knowledge to kill Lord Hastings.  The King purposely ate some strawberries and blamed his allergic reaction on a curse from Lord Hastings.  Lord Hasting's was beheaded as punishment, and his head was served on a platter.

In 1656 a French doctor named Pierre Borel suspected one of his patients developed a rash when this patient ate eggs.  So one day he attempted to test his theory by placing some egg particles on the patient's skin.  When blisters developed on the patient's skin the physician knew he had made the correct diagnosis.

Dr. Morell Mackenzie writes that In 1565 Dr. Botallus (the man who's name is applied to the foramen ovale in the heart) recognized that many of his patients developed sniffling, sneezing and facial irritation when they smelled roses.  The condition was thus dubbed rose cold or rose fever.  (3, page 18) (6, page 93)(8)

Mackenzie notes that "This observer, therefore, came very near the mark to the real cause of the disease, to which he applied the term coryza a rosarum odore.'

Jan Baptise van Helmont (1579-1644), who helped define asthma, also noted the symptoms of hay fever.  (3, page 18)  Vanhelmont noted that in some of his patients "sweet smelling causing headache, and in some cases difficulty breathing." (6, page 93)

In 1673 I.N Binningerus wrote that he was informed several times by professor James A. Brun of the University of Bastle that is wife, Ursula Falcisin, "suffered from coryza for several weeks every year during the rose season."  (6, page 93)

In 1691 I. Constant Rebecque described how "for thirteen years he had been afflicted with coryza during the rose season...  At first he attributed his sufferings to heat, but in the year 1685, when the summer was exceptionally hot and there were hardly any roses on account of caterpillars, he was struck by the fact his annual disorder did not trouble him.  The symptoms came on at once, however, after inadvertently plucking a rose toward the end of the season.  He concludes that something flows from roses which stings the nose" (7, page 93)

Seventeenth century physician John Floyer noted, in 1698, that asthma symptoms lasted longer and were more "acute" in summer than in the winter.  (3, page 18)  Eighteenth century physician William Cullen may have been referring to hay fever when he wrote that "in some persons asthmatic fits are more frequent in summer, and more particularly during the dog-days, than at other colder seasons of the year," wrote Charle's Blackley in 1873 (I'll write more about him later). (4)

William Heberden (1710-1801) wrote on the subject of catarrh: "I have known it (catarrh) to return in four or five persons annually in the months of April, May, June and July, and last a month with great violence." Heberden's book was published posthumously in 1802 and edited by his son.  (5, page 14)

Mackenzie explains that Heberden made a connection between "rose catarrh of the seventeenth century and the hay fever of the nineteenth, for though this physician does not seem to have been at all aware that the complaint had any connection with flowering plants, he mentions casually that five of his patients suffered from catarrh for a month every summer, while another was similarly affected during the whole of that season."

Various other physicians made references to hay fever or rose fever, such as by C.L. Parry in London in 1801 and 1809.  Or by Elliotson in 1821 who "tells of a patient who had had hay-fever since 1789, and another who was sixty-six years of age and who had had the disease since his seventh year, i.e. since 1755, and of a third who had been afflicted for many years. (3, page 18-19)

Finally, in 1819, the condition would be recognized by the medical community.  By that time the term hay-fever had been around for many years, although there is no evidence as to who created the term, where, and when is a mystery.

References:
  1. Cantani, "Pediatric Allergy, Asthma and Immunology," 2000, New York, page 724
  2. Ehrlich, Paul M., Elizabeth Shimer Bowers, "Living with Allergies," 2008
  3. Hollopeter, William Clarence, "Hay-fever and its successful treatment," 1898, Philadelphia, P. Blakiston's Son & Co.
  4. Blackely, Charles Harrison, "Hay-fever: its causes, treatment, and effective prevention," 1873, 1880 2nd edition, London, Bailliere
  5. Smith, William Abbotts, "On Hay-Fever, Hay-Asthma, or Summer Catarrh," 1867, London, Henry Renshaw
  6. Mackenzie, Morell Sir, "Hay fever and paroxysmal sneezing," 5th edition, 1889, London, J&A Churchill, also see Morell Mackenzie, "On Hay Fever and Rose Fever," The Medical Record, New York, August, 1884, vol. 26. no. 9, page 225
  7. Mackenzie, Morell, ibid, Sir Mackenzie notes here that "This observer, therefore, came very near the mark to the real cause of the disease, to which he applied the term coryza a rosarum odore.'
  8. Koessler, Karl K., "The Specific Treatment of hay fever (pollen disease)," page 665, of "Forchheimer's Therapeusis of Internal diseases," Frederick Forchheimer, edited by Frank Billings and Ernest E. Irons, Volume V, 1920, New York and London, D. Appleton and Company